Where Did My Lakefront Go?


When the Water Moves, Does Your Property Line Move With It?

If you have owned property on Pelican Lake for any length of time, you already know the lake does not stay put.

Some years the water is high. Other years it is low. Beaches appear and disappear. A point may become more pronounced. A shallow area may gradually fill in. At another location, waves and ice may slowly eat away at the shoreline.

That raises an interesting property law question: If the shoreline moves, does your property line move with it?

Sometimes, yes.

Like most things involving real estate law, however, there is more to the answer.

Illustration of Minnesota lakefront boundaries, showing accretion, reliction, erosion, avulsion, ordinary high water level, and the current water’s edge.

Your Deed May Be More Informative Than You Think

We normally think of property boundaries as fixed. A surveyor locates the corners, sets monuments and draws lines between them. Those lines generally do not move.

A boundary along a lake can be different.

If your property is truly riparian, meaning your legal description extends to the lake, the water itself can form one of the boundaries of the property. Minnesota has long recognized that a riparian property owner may gain land through accretion or reliction and may lose land through erosion.

Those are old legal terms for some fairly simple concepts.

Accretion is the gradual addition of soil to the shoreline through natural forces.

Reliction occurs when water gradually recedes and exposes land that was previously covered by water.

Erosion works in the opposite direction. The shoreline is gradually worn away.

When those changes occur gradually and naturally, the legal boundary can generally move with the shoreline.

So, suppose your grandparents purchased a Pelican Lake cabin 60 years ago. At that time, there were 50 feet between the cabin and the water. Over many years, the shoreline gradually moved farther away and additional dry land appeared.

It is entirely possible that the family now owns more land than appeared to exist when your grandparents bought the property.

Of course, the reverse can also happen. A riparian owner can lose land to gradual erosion.

The lake giveth and the lake taketh away.

But What About the Ordinary High Water Level?

This is where things can get confusing.

Lake owners frequently hear the term Ordinary High Water Level, or OHWL. It is easy to assume that the OHWL is simply the legal property line.

It is not that simple.

The OHWL is particularly important as a regulatory and/or jurisdictional boundary. The Minnesota DNR defines it generally as the highest water level maintained long enough to leave evidence on the landscape, often where vegetation changes from predominantly aquatic to predominantly terrestrial.

It determines, among other things, where certain DNR permitting requirements begin. Counties also use it for shoreland setbacks and other zoning regulations.

But the OHWL, the water’s edge on a particular August afternoon and the boundary of privately owned property are not necessarily the same thing.

A person may own land and still be restricted in what can be done with it. Ownership does not automatically mean you can fill, excavate, install riprap, remove vegetation or otherwise alter the shoreline without government approval.

What If the Lake Moves Suddenly?

The rules concerning accretion, reliction and erosion generally contemplate changes that occur gradually.

A sudden and identifiable change to a water boundary is traditionally called avulsion.

Think of the difference this way. If the shoreline changes a few inches or feet at a time over many years, that is the type of gradual change for which the accretion and reliction rules were developed.

If a major event suddenly creates a new channel or dramatically relocates a shoreline, the analysis can be different. The law generally does not allow a sudden event to rearrange everyone’s property ownership overnight in the same manner as gradual natural movement.

Fortunately, most of what we see around Pelican involves the slower variety.

Your Survey Is Important But It May Not Answer Everything

This can also produce an interesting surveying issue.

Suppose you pull out a survey from 1982. It accurately shows the shoreline as it existed in 1982.

That does not necessarily mean the line drawn on that survey forever fixes the legal shoreline at that location.

The survey is evidence of where things were at that time. If the parcel is actually bounded by the lake, later natural changes may have changed the boundary.

The precise language of the legal description therefore matters greatly.

There is a significant difference between owning land to the lake and owning a fixed parcel that happens to be near the lake.

I have encountered properties where everyone involved assumed for decades that a parcel was riparian, only to discover that an old road, separate tract, government lot, railroad interest or unusual legal description existed between the owner’s parcel and the water.

Before debating where a riparian boundary moved, we first need to establish that the property actually has one.

The Practical Lesson

For most Pelican Lake owners, none of this requires doing anything.

Water levels will rise and fall. Shorelines will gradually change. That has been happening longer than any of us have been here.

The issue becomes important when someone is buying or selling property, ordering a survey, building near the water, installing or relocating a dock, altering the shoreline or disputing a boundary with a neighbor.

At that point, do not assume that today’s waterline, an old survey, the OHWL or the location where everyone has historically mowed the grass necessarily answers the ownership question.

Start with the deed and legal description. Determine whether the property is actually riparian. Look at the survey history and physical changes to the shoreline. And, when appropriate, involve both a surveyor familiar with riparian boundaries and legal counsel before turning a disagreement into a much more expensive problem.

Minnesota may be the Land of 10,000 Lakes but for many it becomes the land of 10,000 legal questions.

— Mark A. Severson